Skip to Content
  • Home
  • About the Bar
  • Mission
  • Forms
  • Sitemap
    • Member Directory
      Last Name:
      First Name:
      Bar Number:
      City:


    • Login
OSB Logo

Oregon State Bar Bulletin — NOVEMBER 2007
Bar Counsel
Stricter Rules:
Public Lawyers Negotiating For Private Employment
By Helen Hierschbiel

Some people are born to public service and will remain there throughout their careers. Others see it either as respite from the vagaries of private practice or as a stepping stone to a more lucrative private practice. Making a move from the public to the private sector definitely has its challenges. For one, public employees, judges, arbitrators, mediators and other third-party neutrals must abide by strict ethics rules that prohibit them from negotiating for employment under certain circumstances. The rules for public lawyers are more rigid than those applied to private law practitioners in similar job negotiation situations. Because they are more rigorous, understanding how they work becomes even more important.

The Rules
Oregon RPC 1.11(d)(2)(vi) provides that a lawyer who is currently serving as a public officer or employee shall not:

negotiate for private employment with any person who is involved as a party or as lawyer for a party in a matter in which the lawyer is participating personally and substantially, except that a lawyer serving as a law clerk or staff lawyer to or otherwise assisting in the official duties of a judge, other adjudicative officer or arbitrator may negotiate for private employment as permitted by Rule 1.12(b) and subject to the conditions stated in Rule 1.12(b).1

By contrast, when lawyers in private practice are interested in pursuing employment with adverse parties or adverse lawyers in a pending matter, they must consider whether they have a personal conflict of interest. Under Oregon RPC 1.7(a)(2), if there is a substantial risk that a lawyer’s responsibilities to a client may be materially limited by the lawyer’s interest in a prospective job, then the lawyer must, at minimum, obtain the client’s informed consent, confirmed in writing, before continuing with either the job negotiations or the client’s pending legal matter. See, ABA Formal Op No 96-400. Thus, unlike for lawyers in private practice who are looking for another job with an adverse party or lawyer, the prohibition against employment negotiations for government lawyers is absolute: the conflict cannot be waived.

Personal and Substantial Participation
The issue of lawyers working on a matter for the government while exploring employment prospects with the participants and their law firms has not been an important source of disciplinary actions or ethics opinions. See Annotated Model Rules of Professional Conduct, 5th ed., at 206 (2003). However, there is some authority in other jurisdictions that discusses "personal and substantial participation" in the context of the government lawyer conflict rules in Oregon RPC 1.11, which should also be relevant to the interpretation of Oregon RPC 1.11(d)(2)(vi). See, e.g., D.C. Ethics Op 315 (2002)(former lawyer with the Environmental Protection Agency was allowed to represent private clients in litigation to challenge the EPA’s final rules, even though he drafted status reports and was involved in discussions about the timing of the rule-making proceedings, because he was not involved in the litigation, but only in peripheral administrative issues).

OSB Formal Op No 2005-120 also explores the conflict issues when switching between government and private practice,2 but does not really discuss the issue of what exactly personal and substantial participation means or how it might be applied to a particular set of facts. The opinion does cite ABA Formal Ethics Op No 342 (1975), which defines the phrase substantial responsibility in light of former DR 9-101: "‘Substantial responsibility’… contemplates a responsibility requiring the official to become personally involved to an important, material degree, in the investigative or deliberative processes regarding the transactions or facts in question…"

Matter
The term matter, unlike the phrase personal and substantial participation, is specifically defined in Oregon RPC 1.0(i) to include:

…any judicial or other proceeding, application, request for a ruling or other determination, contract, claim, controversy, investigation, charge, accusation, arrest or other particular matter involving a specific party or parties; and any other matter covered by the conflict of interest rules of a government agency.

Notably, the definition excludes legislation, rule-making and other policy determinations. It is identical to the definition adopted in the ABA Model Rule 1.11(e), which originated in ABA Formal Ethics Op 342 (1975):

[W]ork as a government employee in drafting, enforcing or interpreting government or agency procedures, regulations, or laws, or in briefing abstract principles of law does not disqualify the lawyer [under Model Code DR 9-101(b)] from subsequent private employment involving the same regulations, procedures or points of law; the same "matter" is not involved because there is lacking the discrete, identifiable transactions or conduct involving a particular situation and specific parties.

Recognize too, that a matter may continue in a different form. In determining whether matters are the same, "…the lawyer should consider the extent to which the matters involve the same basic facts, the same or related parties, and the time elapsed." ABA Model Rule 1.11, Comment [10].

Negotiations
Assuming that a government lawyer is personally and substantially participating in a matter, the issue becomes whether the lawyer is engaged in negotiations for employment. I have found no authority that defines negotiating for employment as prohibited by Rule 1.11(d). According to the Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary, negotiate means "to confer with another so as to arrive at the settlement of some matter… to arrange for or bring about through conference, discussion, and compromise." The definition suggests that negotiation requires some active discussion with another about a particular matter with the goal of arriving at an agreement. Thus, if a government lawyer simply peruses the classifieds, has general discussions about job interests or makes limited inquiry about job possibilities, these activities would not seem to rise to the level of negotiating for employment.

Although there is no authority directly discussing Oregon RPC 1.11(d)(2)(vi) and job negotiations, ABA Formal Op No 96-400 addresses the ethics of a private lawyer engaging in job negotiations with an adverse firm or party. In attempting to identify the point at which a personal conflict arises that requires client consultation, the ABA Legal Ethics Committee examines the lawyer’s role in the representation and the extent to which the lawyer’s interest in the employment with the adverse firm is concrete, communicated and reciprocated. When a lawyer agrees to participate in a substantive discussion of his experience, business potential or terms of association, the opinion says there would be a conflict that requires disclosure and consent from the client. By analogy, a government lawyer’s substantive discussions with an adverse firm or party with the goal of securing employment would clearly constitute negotiations prohibited by Oregon RPC 1.11(d)(2)(vi).

Although the ABA opinion makes a valiant effort at drawing a line in the sand that private lawyers should not cross without client consent, that line may not fully apply to the government lawyer situation and may move depending on the circumstances. In other words, without some authority, do not assume that anything less than the substantive discussions are allowed.

Conclusion
In many cases, the obvious answer to the problem of negotiating for private employment with an adverse party or firm is for the government lawyer to wait until the matter is concluded or to disengage from any personal or substantial participation in the matter. When this solution is not feasible, particularly for those government lawyers who work in small communities, lawyers are advised to tread cautiously, because the rule prohibiting negotiations is a rigorous one with little guidance from authorities on how it would be applied in any given situation.

Note: The bar’s Legal Ethics Committee is in the process of drafting an opinion on this subject, which may help clarify the issues raised in this column.

Endnotes
1 Oregon RPC 1.12(b) also prohibits judges and other third-party neutrals from negotiating for employment with parties to matters in which they are participating personally and substantially, but allows law clerks to do so as long as they first notify their judges.

2 OSB Formal Op No 2005-120 was recently amended to clarify the rules regarding imputation of conflicts applicable to current and former government lawyers.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Helen Hierschbiel is deputy general counsel for the Oregon State Bar. She can be reached at (503) 620-0222, or toll-free in Oregon at (800) 452-8260, ext. 361, or by e-mail at hhierschbiel@osbar.org.

© 2007 Helen Hierschbiel


— return to top
— return to Table of Contents

  • For The Public

      Public Legal Information

    • Public Information Home
    • Legal Information Topics
    • Oregon Juror Guide
    • Submit Ethics Complaint

    • Getting Legal Help

    • Finding The Right Lawyer
    • Hiring A Lawyer
    • Lawyers Fees

    • Client Services

    • Client Assistance Office
    • Client Security Fund
    • Fee Dispute Resolution
    • Public Records Request
    • Locating Attorney Files

    • Unlawful Practice of Law

    • UPL Information
    • UPL FAQ

    • Volunteer Opportunities

    • Public Member Application
  • For Members

    OSB Login

    • Log In To OSB Site
    • Member Account Setup
    • Non-Member Account Setup
    • Reset Password

    OSB Resources

    • Attorney's Marketplace
    • Career Center
    • Events
    • Forms Library
    • Online Resources
    • OSB Group Listings
    • Performance Standards
    • Rules Regulations and Policies
    • Surveys and Research Reports
    • Unclaimed Client Funds
    • Voting Regions and By-City
      County Information

    Fastcase™

    • Log in to Fastcase
    • Overview
    • Scheduled Webinars
    • Inactive Member Subscriptions

    Legal Ethics

    • Legal Ethics Home
    • Find an Ethics Opinion
    • Bulletin Bar Counsel Archive

    Company Administrator

    • Company Administrator Home
    • Company Administrator FAQ
    • Authorization Form

    State Lawyers
    Assistance Committee

    • SLAC Info

    Volunteering

    • Volunteer Opportunities

    Court Information

    • Judicial Vacancies
    • Court Info | Calendars | Jury Info
    • Oregon Attorneys
      in Federal Court
    • Tribal Courts of Oregon

    OSB Publications

    • Bar Bulletin Magazine
    • – Bulletin Archive
    • – Legal Writer Archive
    • Capitol Insider
    • Disciplinary Board Reporter

    PLF Programs

    • (OAAP) Oregon Attorney
      Assistance Program
    • Practice Management Attorneys
    • Malpractice Coverage
  • CLE/Legal Publications

    CLE Seminars

    • CLE Seminars Home
    • Online Seminar Registration
    • General Info/FAQ

    My Account

    • My Content
    • My Events
    • Order History

    Legal Publications

    • Legal Publications Home
    • Log in to BarBooks®
    • BarBooks® FAQ
    • Online Bookstore
    • Legal Pubs Blog
  • Bar Programs

    Diversity & Inclusion

    • Diversity & Inclusion Home
    • Diversity Story Wall
    • D&I Programs
    • ACDI Roster
    • D&I Staff Contacts
    • D&I Links

    Legislative/Public Affairs

    • Legislative Home
    • Committee Contacts
    • Legislative Sessions
    • Staff Contacts
    • Useful Links

    Legal Services Program

    • LSP Home

    Oregon Law Foundation

    • OLF Home
    • Partners in Justice

    Fee Dispute Resolution

    • Fee Dispute Resolution Home

    Pro Bono

    • Pro Bono Home
    • Pro Bono Reporting
    • Volunteer Opportunities

    Lawyer Referral and Information Services

    • RIS Login
    • Summary of Referral and Information Services Programs
    • Lawyer Referral Service Info and Registration Forms
    • Modest Means Program Registration Forms
    • Military Assistance Panel Training Info and Registration Form
    • Problem Solvers Registration Form
    • Lawyer To Lawyer Registration Form

    (LRAP) Loan Repayment Assistance Program

    • LRAP Home
    • LRAP FAQ
    • LRAP Policies
  • Member Groups

    Sections

    • Section Info/Websites
    • Joining Sections
    • CLE Registration Services
    • Standard Section Bylaws (PDF)
    • Leadership Resources
    • Treasurers Tools

    Committees

    • Home
    • Leadership Resources
    • Professionalism Commission
    • Volunteer Opportunities

    House of Delegates

    • HOD Home
    • HOD Resources
    • Meetings
    • Rules (PDF)
    • Roster (PDF)
    • Staff Contacts

    Board of Governors

    • BOG Home
    • Meetings & Agendas
    • Members
    • Liaisons
    • Committees
    • Resources
    • Task Forces

    Oregon New Lawyers Division

    • ONLD Home
    • Law Students
    • Student Loan Repayment
    • Committees
    • Upcoming Events

    Task Forces and Special Committees

    • Task Forces Home

    Volunteer Bars

    • List/Contacts
    • Leadership Resources

    Volunteering

    • Volunteer Opportunities
  • Licensing/Compliance

    Admissions

    • Admissions Home
    • Alternative Admittance
    • Applicants for Admission
    • Admissions Forms
    • Past Bar Exam Results

    Supervised Practice Portfolio Examination

    • SPPE Home

    Licensed Paralegal Program

    • LP Home

    Lawyer Discipline

    • Discipline Home
    • Disciplinary Board Reporter
    • Disciplinary Boards
    • Client Assistance Office
    • (SPRB) State Professional Responsibility Board

    Membership Records

    • Address Changes
    • Good Standing Certificate
    • Request Discipline File Review

    MCLE

    • MCLE Home
    • Program Database
    • Forms
    • Rules (PDF)

    IOLTA Reporting

    • IOLTA Home
    • IOLTA FAQ

    Licensing Fees

    • Licensing Fee FAQ
    • Licensing Fee Payment

    Status Changes

    • Status Changes FAQ
    • Inactive Status Form
    • Retired Status Form
    • Active Pro Bono Status Form
    • Reinstatement Forms
    • Resignation Form A
    • Pending Reinstatements

    Unlawful Practice of Law

    • UPL Information
    • UPL FAQ

    Pro Hac Vice/Arbitration

    • Pro Hac Vice
    • Arbitration

    New Lawyer Mentoring Program

    • New Lawyer Mentoring Program Home

    Professional Liability Fund

    • Professional Liability
      Fund Website
For The Public

Public Information Home
Legal Information Topics
Oregon Juror Guide
Finding The Right Lawyer
Hiring A Lawyer
Lawyers Fees
Client Assistance Office
Public Records Request
Unlawful Practice of Law
Fee Dispute Resolution
Client Security Fund
Volunteer Opportunities
for the Public

For Members

BarBooks®
Bulletin Archive
Career Center
Fastcase™
Judicial Vacancies
Legal Ethics Opinions
OSB Group Listings
OSB Login
OSB Rules & Regs
SLAC Info
Surveys and Reports
Volunteer Opportunities

CLE/Legal Pubs

CLE Seminars Home
Legal Publications Home

Bar Programs

Diversity & Inclusion
Fee Arbitration/Mediation
Legal Services Program
Legislative/Public Affairs
Loan Repayment
Assistance Program

Oregon Law Foundation
Pro Bono

Member Groups

Board of Governors
Committees
House of Delegates
Volunteer Bars
Oregon New
Lawyers Division

OSB Sections
Professionalism
Commission

Volunteer Opportunities

About The Bar

About the Bar
ADA Notice
Contact Info
Copyright Notice
Directions to the Bar
Meeting Room Rentals
Mission Statement
OSB Job Opportunities
Privacy Policy
Staff Directory
Terms of Use

Licensing/Compliance

Admissions
Client Assistance Office
Client Security Fund
IOLTA Reporting
Lawyer Discipline
MCLE
Member Fee FAQ
New Lawyer
Mentoring Program

Professional Liability Fund
Status Changes

Oregon State Bar Center

Phone: (503) 620-0222
Toll-free in Oregon: (800) 452-8260
Facsimile: (503) 684-1366

Building Location:
16037 SW Upper Boones Ferry Road
Tigard, OR 97224

Mailing Address:
PO Box 231935
Tigard, OR 97281

Oregon State Bar location Map

Copyright ©1997 Oregon State Bar  ®All rights reserved | ADA Notice | Mission Statement | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use